Which is the Smallest of Seeds? Resolving Bible Difficulties, Part 2

by Daryl E. Witmer EDITOR'S NOTE: This month's issue of the Proclamation features the second in a three-part series of articles on reasonable solutions to difficult Bible texts. There are many alleged discrepancies in Scripture, but given the right resources, we are convinced that there are sensible ways to unravel every one of them. This series cites three such challenges, their respective solutions, a few key principles for tackling Bible difficulties in general, and two more helpful resources. ALLEGED PROBLEM In Matthew 13:31-32 Jesus said that the mustard seed was "smaller than all other seeds" but that when it was full grown it would be large enough for birds to nest in its branches. Today we know that there are seeds even smaller than the mustard seed. For instance, the orchid seed is so small and fine that it's almost dust-like. There are those who would also question whether a mustard seed could ever grow into a tree that is large enough to hold a bird nest. Now if Jesus (who claimed to be God) was wrong about the mustard seed, why should we trust anything else that He said? And on what basis can the Bible be considered reliable on any scientific or historical matter? SENSIBLE SOLUTION Please note that Jesus was not comparing the mustard seed to all other seeds in the world, but to seeds that a local Palestinian farmer might have "sowed in his field," i.e. a key qualifying phrase in verse 31. And it's absolutely true that the black mustard seed (B. nigra) was the smallest seed ever sown by a first-century farmer in that part of the world. It's also true, as many modern-day encyclopedias will tell you, that the black mustard seed in Israel will typically grow to heights of 3.7 meters, or twelve (12) feet - plenty large enough to hold a bird nest. It's important to remember that the Bible often uses everyday terminology in order to communicate simple truth. Even today we might refer to a "sunset" when, technically, scientifically, we know that the sun never actually 'sets,' i.e. it's the earth that revolves. When people come to visit us here in north central Maine, we might take them on a drive, passing a good number of lakes and ponds, to Moosehead Lake, which I will describe to them as being "the largest lake of all." Of course, our guests will usually realize that I'm speaking locally, not globally. They don't often question my credibility. The context of Matthew 13 makes it quite clear that Jesus was addressing a local lay audience, not an international conference of botanists. It seems that no reasonable person would therefore insist for very long that this text provides a viable basis for questioning either Jesus or the Bible when it comes to getting the facts straight - scientifically, historically, or technically. RELEVANT PRINCIPLES FOR DEALING WITH BIBLE DIFFICULTIES - KEEP THE TEXT IN CONTEXT. Failing to consider the historical and Biblical context of a particular verse or passage may be the most common mistake of all. But it's crucial to an accurate understanding of the text. The Bible doesn't approve of every-one whom it quotes or talks about. - SUBJECT THE OBSCURE TO THE STRAIGHTFORWARD. The Bible is clear about many things, so always allow that which is clear to be a guide in unraveling that which is not clear. In others words, trust the perspicuity of Scripture. As the old adage goes, "Let the main things be the plain things, and the plain things be the main things." - ALLOW FOR PARTIAL ACCOUNTS, QUOTES, AND PARTICULAR POINTS OF VIEW. Don't always assume that a report or a quote is wrong just because it happens to be less than 100% complete. - ACKNOWLEDGE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CITATIONS AND QUOTATIONS. Many times a passage from the Old Testament may be referenced in the New Testament without necessary being quoted. Why shouldn't a writer be allowed to cite the essence of a text, just as we often do today, without offering an exact word-for-word quote?! - REMEMBER THAT THE BIBLE EMPLOYS LITERARY DEVICES Metaphors, analogies, types, allegories, hyperboles, and similes would all be examples of this. HERE ARE TWO MORE HELPFUL RESOURCES Hard Sayings of the Bible, edited by Kaiser, Davids, Bruce, and Brauch, ©1996 by InterVarsity Press Bible Difficulties Solved, by Larry Richards, ©1993 by Revell